Insurance is a financial safety net that provides individuals and businesses with a sense of security in the face of unexpected events. It serves as a shield against the uncertainties of life, helping policyholders mitigate potential losses. Central to the world of insurance is a set of fundamental principles and concepts that underpin the industry's functioning. One such principle, the Principle of Contribution, plays a pivotal role in ensuring fairness, accuracy, and equitable distribution of risk among insurers and policyholders.

In this article, we will dive deep into the intricate world of insurance and explore the principle of contribution in detail. We will shed light on how it operates, its significance, and the implications it carries for both policyholders and insurance providers. Whether you are a seasoned insurance professional or simply curious about how insurance works, understanding the Principle of Contribution is essential to navigating the complexities of the insurance landscape. So, let's demystify this critical concept and gain valuable insights into the world of insurance.

The principle of contribution in insurance

The principle of contribution in insurance is a fundamental concept that comes into play when an individual or entity purchases multiple insurance policies that cover the same risk or property. This principle ensures that in the event of a loss or claim, the policyholder cannot collect more than the actual amount of the loss from all the insurance policies combined. The main idea behind the Principle of Contribution is to prevent over-insurance or profiting from an insurance claim. Insurance is meant to indemnify or compensate the policyholder for their actual loss, not to provide an opportunity for financial gain.

Please note the following important points with respect to the principle of contribution in insurance-

· For the principle of contribution to come into effect, more than one insurance must be involved and all policies insuring the loss must be in force. There is nothing that can be contributed if only one policy is involved. Similarly, if it is discovered at the time of loss that one of the policies in the pool is not in effect for some reason, that policy will not be called upon to contribute.

· The policies must all cover the same matter. If all of the policies cover the same policyholder but distinct subject matters, the question of contribution does not arise.

· Each policy must cover the exact peril that caused the loss or damage. If the policies cover different kinds of perils and the concerned loss is not caused by a common peril, the question of contribution can be avoided.

· All policies must protect the same interest of one single insured. Assume, for example, that "A" owns a car and secured a loan from "B" using the car as collateral. Both A and B have insurable interests in this case and can influence policies independently. In the event of vehicle damage, both A and B will receive claims independently, with no contribution between the policies. The reason for this is that the interests as well as the insureds are different.

It is important to remember that if any of the four factors listed above are not satisfied, the principle of contribution won't apply.

Get Free Quote in Minutes

Principle of Contribution and Insurer

Contribution is the right of an insurer who has paid under a policy. He can call other insurers who are interested in the loss to pay or contribute to the payment. This means that if it is discovered at the time of loss that many policies cover the same loss, all policies should pay the loss proportionately to the extent of their respective responsibilities.

If a certain insurer pays the entire loss, that insurer has the right to demand that the other insurers pay him back to the extent of their individual liabilities. Under no circumstances can the insured be permitted to take benefit of all policies separately, in order to receive the entire claim multiple times. Even if the insured recovers from all policies, he must return any payments made in excess of the actual loss.

How is the extent of contribution calculated amongst multiple insurers?

Once it is confirmed that the factors mentioned above are satisfying, the contribution principle comes into effect. The next step is to determine the liability under every insurance policy at the time of a claim settlement. Typically, this is done on a sum-insured basis for each insurance policy and is sometimes referred to as the proportionate liability or respective liability of each individual policy.

The formula used is = (Sum insured under each policy / Total sum insured under all policies) X Loss Amount

Here is an example to make it clearer to you:

Consider the case when the same asset is covered by three different policies, namely

Policy A with sum insured of Rs. 1 Cr.

Policy B with sum insured of Rs. 2 Cr.

Policy C with sum insured of Rs. 3 Cr.

Therefore, the total sum insured combining all the policies is Rs. 1 Cr. + Rs. 2 Cr. + Rs. 3 Cr. = Rs. 6 Cr.

Now, in the event of a covered loss of Rs. 1 Cr., the individual contribution of the respective policies will be as follows –

Policy A = 1/6 X Rs. 1 Cr. = 0.167 Cr.

Policy B = 2/6 X Rs. 1 Cr. = 0.333 Cr.

Policy C = 3/6 X Rs. 1 Cr. = 0.500 Cr.

Why is the principle of contribution important in insurance?

The Principle of Contribution is important in insurance for several key reasons:

1.Prevents Over-Insurance: It ensures that policyholders do not profit from a loss or claim by collecting more than the actual financial loss incurred. This helps maintain the integrity of the insurance system and prevents individuals from insuring the same risk for more than its actual value.

2. Fair Allocation of Costs: The principle ensures that the cost of an insurance claim is distributed fairly among all the insurers involved. Without this principle, one insurer could be unfairly burdened with the entire cost of a loss, which could lead to increased premiums for that insurer's policyholders.

3. Avoids Moral Hazard: Moral hazard refers to the tendency of individuals to take greater risks when they know they are over-insured or can benefit from a loss. The Principle of Contribution helps mitigate moral hazard by discouraging policyholders from intentionally causing losses to profit from insurance claims.

4. Maintains Insurability: Over-insurance can lead to increased costs for insurers, which can ultimately make insurance less affordable or even unavailable for certain risks. By preventing over-insurance, the Principle of Contribution helps maintain the overall insurability of risks.

5. Supports Risk Pooling: Insurance relies on the principle of spreading risk across a large pool of policyholders. If policyholders were allowed to collect more than their actual losses, it would disrupt the equilibrium of the risk pool and could lead to higher premiums for all policyholders.

6. Legal and Regulatory Compliance: Many jurisdictions have laws and regulations that require adherence to the principle of contribution. Insurers are often required to follow these principles to ensure compliance with the law and to protect consumers.

The Footnote:

In the somewhat complicated domain of insurance, where risk and uncertainty intersect with financial protection, the principle of contribution stands as a beam of fairness and equity. In the discussion above, we tried to grasp the essence of this fundamental concept and uncover its vital role in maintaining the integrity of the insurance industry. The principle of contribution ensures that no policyholder gains an unfair advantage and that each insurer involved in a claim bears its appropriate share of the financial burden. With the proper knowledge of this principle, policyholders can make informed decisions, insurers can uphold their commitments, and the insurance ecosystem can continue to thrive.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What are the 7 principles of insurance?

The seven fundamental principles of insurance are:

· Principle of Utmost Good Faith

· Principle of Insurable Interest

· Principle of Indemnity

· Principle of Subrogation

· Principle of Proximate Cause

· Principle of Contribution, and

· Principle of Loss Minimization

2. What is the Principle of Indemnity in insurance?

The Principle of Indemnity in insurance is a fundamental concept that states that an insurance policy is designed to compensate the policyholder for their actual financial loss, without allowing them to profit from a claim. In essence, it ensures that the policyholder is restored to the same financial position they were in before the insured event occurred, rather than being placed in a better position. This principle prevents policyholders from receiving more money than they have actually lost and promotes the idea that insurance is meant to provide financial recovery, not financial gain.

3. What is the Principle of Subrogation in insurance?

The Principle of Subrogation in insurance is a legal concept that allows an insurance company, after paying a claim to its policyholder, to step into the policyholder's shoes and pursue any rights or legal actions that the policyholder may have against third parties responsible for the loss.

In other words, if an insurance company pays a claim to its insured due to damage caused by a third party, the insurer can then seek reimbursement from that third party for the amount it paid to the insured. Subrogation helps prevent the insured from collecting twice for the same loss and allows the insurance company to recover some or all of the money it paid out in claims, ultimately helping to keep insurance costs lower for the policyholders.

Here is all about D&O insurance

Here is all about CGL insurance